Affiliate Disclaimer: This post may contain links that will earn us a commission at no cost to you. This helps keep Weldguru a free resource for our readers.
When I first started welding, wire-feed welders were among the first I learned on and there were two different wires used: MIG and flux-cored wires.
The first question I had was what’s the difference? Then I asked if one was better or if one was cheaper. You get the idea, I had lots of questions about the two options, just like most users.
So, if you’re new to welding and have similar questions, you came to the right place. In this article, we’ll cover the good and the bad, as well as where to use either of these two popular welding processes.
MIG vs Flux-Core Comparison TableMIG Flux-cored Setup/Learning curve Moderate Moderate Wire Cost ✅ $$ ⛔ $$$ Requires Gas Tank ⛔ Yes ✅ No Operating Cost $$ $$ Surface prep ⛔ Bright white metal is best ✅ Works through paint, rust, and dirt Wind ⛔ Indoor, Less than 5 MPH ✅ Outdoor, Up to 35 MPH Bead Appearance ✅ No slag, little spatter ⛔ Slag & spatter Post clean Up ✅ Very Little ⛔ Slag & Spatter Cleaning Thin stock ✅ Down to 24 ga. ⛔ 1/8 or thicker Thick stock ⛔ Acceptable with enough power ✅ Good penetration up to 3/8in. Cast iron ⛔ Possible, but weaker weld ✅ Better penetration, stronger than MIG Aluminum ✅ Cleaner than stick ⛔ Possible but messier Mobility ⛔ Harder with gas tanks ✅ Easier without gas tanks
Solid MIG Wire
Flux-Core vs. MIG Welding – The Similarities
An obvious similarity, both flux-cored and MIG welding involves feeding a spool of wire automatically to the welding torch. This has the advantage of reducing the need to constantly replace your consumable electrode, which you need to do when stick welding.
The wire acts as an electrode with both types of wire. The wire electrode is consumed during the weld, and hence the need to continuously feed wire to the torch. So, both wires are vital as they carry current and support the welding arc, as well as supply the filler material for your weld.
While you will find dedicated MIG and flux-cored welders, many MIG units can weld using both MIG and flux-cored wire. That’s because the process of using a consumable wire electrode is very similar for both types of wire, except for a significant difference we will discuss in a bit.
Related read: Arc Welding Explained: What is it? & How Does it Work?
Also, both wires can weld aluminum, steel, stainless steel, which makes both wire types versatile, although in some cases on will be preferable as we will cover in the next section.
The basic setup for gas metal arc welding (“GMAW), or metal inert gas (“MIG”) welding is shown below.
For comparison, below is an illustration of the flux-cored arc welding (“FCAW”) process.
Flux-Core vs. MIG Welding – The Differences
Those who looked carefully at the diagrams of both processes will notice they are quite similar. But not 100%.
The main difference between flux-core and MIG welding is that flux-core welding does not require a shielding gas which makes it more portable. This also makes flux-core more suited to welding in windy conditions. The self-shielding flux-cored wire provides the shielding gas when burned.
There are more differences but let’s break these down below.
The most obvious difference, the MIG process uses a tank of gas. This gas is fed to the torch along with the wire. It’s very important for a successful MIG weld. That’s because it shields the weld puddle from the gasses in the air, which can react with your hot weld and cause defects.
When flux-cored welding, you face the same “air” contamination problem. But this form of welding provides shielding to the weld using flux contained inside a hollow-core inside the wire. Hence the name “flux-cored” wire.
The flux reacts with the weld’s high heat at the torch and releases a protective gas. It also produces a shell of slag, that “crusts” over the weld. So, a tank of compressed gas is not needed.
This ability to produce its own shielding gas earned flux-cored welding the nickname “gasless MIG.” But as we just explained, it is not gasless. It generates a shielding gas to protect the hot weld, and the “gasless” moniker refers to the fact you don’t need a tank of gas.
There are flux-cored wires the use both gas from a tank and the additional protection provided by flux. This is referred to as dual-shielded welding. For this reason, you often find flux-cored wires categorized as dual shielded or self-shielding. But self-shielding is the most common.
MIG and flux-cored both bring advantages and disadvantages. For instance, the MIG shielding gas can be changed by changing out the tank. That can be useful when you weld a wide range of metals. You have more control. Aluminum for example works best with pure Argon.
So, MIG welding then means you have to have tanks of compressed gas on hand, and possibly more than one if you work with more than just steel. Tanks are heavy and need to be handled to prevent toppling over. Plus, you need accessories like hoses and regulators.
With a flux-cored wire, you normally don’t need gas tanks, but you need to have the right alloy wire and flux core mixture for the weld at hand. This involves keeping various wires if you weld varying metals. Storage can be an issue, and that brings us to the flux-cored wire construction.
Read more: Shielding gas for MIG welding – What to use
We already touched on the construction differences of both wires. MIG wire is solid. But the flux-cored wire is in essence a hollow tube filled with flux and some other important additives.
A cross-section would look like the diagram below:Cross section of flux-cored wire
For flux-cored welding, you have to buy a specific wire with the metal alloy and the right core compounds, depending on the weld you need to do. This can get complicated and it means you may have many different wires to handle and store.
Also, some flux-cored wires need cool, low humidity conditions, or they can absorb moisture and go bad. So, there are a variety of flux-cored wires you may need to keep on hand and store properly if you rely on flux-cored wire only in your shop.
Look closely at the diagrams for each process, and you’ll see MIG and flux-cored welding have different polarities on the torch. The MIG torch electrode is set to positive, while the torch electrode is set to negative for a flux-cored wire.
So, if you switch from one type of wire to the other, and you must change the polarity. The correct polarity is needed for quality welds or you risk burn throughs or excess spatter.
As mentioned earlier, with MIG welding, the torch is positive and the work is negative. That means the current jumps from the workpiece to the wire. This setting is called direct current electrode positive (“DCEP”) and it concentrates more heat in the workpiece. It is also sometimes called reversed polarity.
In flux-cored welding, the electrode is often negative, and the workpiece is positive. The current jumps from the wire electrode to the workpiece. But be aware, some flux-cored wires do require a DCEP arrangement, so you must pay attention to your polarity when doing flux-cored welding.
The electrode negative arrangement is called direct current, electrode negative (“DCEN”), or sometimes just straight polarity. You get more heat in the electrode with DCEN.
In short, the current direction impacts how and where heat is concentrated during a weld. DCEP results in more heat in the base metal and better penetration. DCEN results in more heat in the electrode and less penetration.
Therefore, welds created with DCEN result in lighter penetration, with more heat in the electrode. So, DCEN welds are usually wider and shallower than the welds produced by DCEP. For this reason, DCEN is often used for thinner metal or parts with a poor fit-up.
The other benefit of DCEN is the resulting higher heat in the electrode is perfect for flux-cored. Remember, the flux and additives in the core of flux-cored wire need heat to work. The EN polarity places the high heat in the right place for the flux inside the wire to work.
Polarity changes can be an issue for some MIG welders. Not all of them can swap polarity. If they don’t, they can not run most flux-cored wires. If you want to run both types of wire, you need to buy a MIG unit that can easily change the torch polarity.
With flux-cored wired, there are additives in the core along with the flux. This is an important difference between the flux-cored and solid wires, Technically, they provide different filler materials. While not a huge issue, there are some things to know.
The wire “shell” alloy and flux mixture in the center of an FCAW wire are designed to work with a specific metal. This allows the reacted flux to float to the surface as slag, and cover the bead. The resulting bead is a very similar alloy to the base metal being welded. But it is different.
For example, some grades of flux-cored wire have higher manganese, which makes the weld unsuitable for multiple passes. This is because the manganese makes the weld more susceptible to work hardening and multiple passes can make the joint brittle or cause it to crack.
You will find flux-cored wires rated for single or multiple passes for the reasons just stated. If you need to make multiple passes, be sure to use a flux-cored wire rated for it.
With MIG wire, it is solid metal, so the weld filler material is “purer” compared to FCAW. It is, therefore, more forgiving and suitable for multiple passes. Plus the alloy is often identical to the metal being welded.
Following up on the filler material discussion, you might think MIG welding results in a stronger weld. But in actual use, both of the MIG and flux-cored wires make very similar strength welds. With one very important caveat, that they are done right.
That means using the right wire for the base metal being joined, correct welder settings, proper technique, etc. needs to be employed for the wire being used. But if the joint is properly welded, there is not a significant difference in strength between the two wires.
One of the notable differences in strength is found with cast iron. Flux-cored wire does result in stronger welds with better penetration in this case. For this reason, cast iron is usually best done using FCAW.
At some point, you will hear that flux-cored wire penetrates better. But is that really true?
The answer is not as simple as you may think. Since the heat is concentrated in the FCAW electrode, you get more focused “heat,” which means it penetrates differently than GMAW.
This means for the same amperage, you get better penetration with flux-cored wire. This can be important if you are welding thicker pieces and pushing your welder. With flux-cored wire, that extra penetration may be needed if you have your welder is set to max amps for the job.
But both flux-cored wire and MIG wire penetrate well. You will need a bit less juice with a flux-cored wire, and some users like to note this by saying that you get more bang for your buck with FCAW.
Another advantage to the flux-cored wire using a few less amps, you can use a smaller generator on remote jobs to get the penetration you need.
MIG vs. Flux Core Welding – Which is Better?
It is almost impossible to say one wire is better than the other, but in certain situations, one wire does become a better choice.
Some of the more common situations you may encounter are:
Anyone who has laid even a few MIG beads knows that GMAW is not forgiving when it comes to rust, dirt, or debris. A pristine, bright white metal surface is best and there are no cutting corners with surface preparation.
But with FCAW, one of the other benefits of the flux used is that it reacts with and removes metal oxides and dirt. It has the ability to cut through the contamination.
So, flux-cored has an advantage if you are in situations where the base metal will have some rust or dirt. For this reason, flux-cored wire is often used in places like shipyards where getting the metal to bright white is difficult.
This is one advantage that is pretty obvious, literally. As the flux reaction produces slag, there is some spitting and sputtering, or spatter.
With MIG wire, there is very little spatter and the resulting GMAW weld is the cleaner-looking option. When clean, pretty welds are needed MIG is the best choice.
OutdoorsWelding outdoors with a flux-core welder
The shielding gas pumped to the torch with the MIG process allows for welds free of slag and with little to no spatter. But if there is a wind, of 5 MPH or higher, the shielding gas is blown away and the hot puddle is exposed to harmful gasses in the air.
So, outdoors where there is wind, flux-cored wire is a better choice. The nature of how the shielding gas is formed combined with the slag encapsulation protects the molten puddle in winds up to 35 MPH.
The MIG process shines compared to the flux-cored wire when it comes to thin stock. If you weld things like autobody pieces, MIG welding is less likely to burn through.
Also, if the piece is to be painted, the cleaner weld (i.e., no slag) is a plus. Slag can make it difficult for paint to bond. If you plan on leaving the welds exposed, the cleaner MIG welds again will be your best choice.
The flux-cored wire does cost more per pound compared to solid MIG wire. But the cost comparison is a bit more complicated.
Flux-cored becomes cheaper when you add in MIG’s cost for the tank of gas, higher upfront cost of a MIG welder, higher amps, etc. Of course, this will vary depending on what welder you buy, which wire you use, the thickness welded, etc. but in general MIG is a bit more expensive.
As we touched on earlier, the flux-cored wire gets penetration and develops stronger weld with cast iron. For this reason, cast iron is usually welded using a flux-cored wire.
MIG’s clean welds are a decided advantage on aluminum. The reduced spatter and absence of slag make for a better-looking weld. Given that much aluminum work is left exposed, the cleaner MIG weld is preferred.
Also, fluxed-cored wires that work in a wire-feed welder don’t actually exist. You will get results with an internet search, but a little more research will reveal these are for brazing, or in fact, they are solid aluminum wires.
For aluminum, MIG is your best and only option, but you may need to buy a spool gun.
If you weld galvanized steel, you will first need to grind off the galvanizing. You cannot weld through it.
But with flux-cored wire, it has the ability to cut through the galvanizing and form a good weld. For galvanized steel, flux-core is the better choice.
Pros vs Cons – Recapped
Solid MIG Wire
Is flux core as strong as MIG?
Both MIG and flux-cored wires make very similar strength welds, and if the joint is properly welded, there is not a significant difference in strength between the processes.
The only notable difference in strength is found with cast iron. Flux-cored wire does result in stronger welds with better penetration in this case. For this reason, cast iron is usually best done using FCAW.
Is MIG welding with gas better than flux core?
If you are working indoors, MIG welds will have the advantage of being more visually appealing and will have no slag to chip off. However, if you are working outside, then flux core welding will be better as it can withstand windy conditions.
Can any MIG welder use flux core?
Most MIG welders are designed to be compatible with flux core wire, however, some MIG welders may not mention this. If your MIG welder does not say, it can most likely weld with a flux core wire with a few changes to the machine.
The main settings to change are the polarity from positive to negative and changing the drive roller so it does not damage the softer flux core wire.
Wrapping It Up
When first learning about welding, many of us hear about MIG’s clean beads that even novice welders can do. So, when I first started welding, I naturally thought MIG solid wire was a better choice than flux-cored.
But I was wrong, flux-cored wire offers many strengths and it is the better choice for certain situations. Knowing when and where the solid or flux-cored wire is a better choice makes you a better welder. So, it is worth your time to learn.
A brief summary might go something like this. Thin stock is best done with solid MIG wire. But when working outdoors in windy conditions you are better of with flux-cored wire. Welding cast iron or galvanized steel, again go with the flux-cored wire. But if you need to weld aluminum, then you need to use the MIG welder with solid wire (and possibly a spool gun).
MIG vs Arc Welding